Is this a good trade?

[EagleFan5]

Is this a good trade?...

I would be offering....
WR- Marvin Harrison
RB- Jamal Lewis

I would be recieving...
WR- Joey Galloway
RB- Edgerrin James

My other recievers are Mushin Muhmammed, Antonio Bryant, and Darrell Jackson
My other running backs are Steven Jackson, Tatum Bell, and Frank Gore

[Hache Man]

Here's something very important to keep in mind regarding Edgerrin James Eagle.......

Edgerrin James - RB - Cardinals

Edgerrin James leads the NFL with 140 "looks" through the first five weeks of the NFL season despite being only 14th in rushing.

While James hasn't justified his high average draft position, he certainly has been given every chance to succeed by Coach Denny Green. These numbers are more of an indictment of the Cardinals disasterous offensive line play, than negatives on James. A "look" is defined as rushing attempts plus targets. Oct. 10 - 3:55 p.m. ET

Source: Rotoworld.com Season Pass

[juice]

I don't think that really helps you. Galloway has a rookie QB throwing the ball and an anemic offense, I haven't checked his numbers but they have to be down. Edge has shit for an offensive line and his numbers are definetely down. The team is always playing from behind too which won't help him out.

Meanwhile, Harrison is always a threat to blow up any given game and Jamal has been getting decent carries and probably will be getting the ball at the goal line. I would pass if I were you, but it's a tough decision.

[sds23]

Take a pass on that deal. The only way that deal makes sense is if you get a much better RB in return for trading a superior WR like Harrison.

Things aren't going to get much better for Edge in Arizona. He may have a decent game or two up his sleeve yet, but by this point in the season we've seen all we need to see to know how the story ends.

Galloway is spectaclular one week and subpar the next. Take it from a fellow fantasy owner who seems to have Galloway on his roster every year...you need to look at his patterns to most effeciently capitalize on him. Some years he will give you two good games in a row, take one off, then give you another good one again. This year, his pattern is "every-other-game" stat-wise. If this holds true, he will be a no show again this weekend. When Galloway shows up he'll net you 16 or 17 points. When he doesn't show up he's as likely to give you between zero and 4 points. Feast or famine with this guy. But if you can tolerate that (he's best used in leagues who start 3 WRs on Sunday) output, he'll post some really respectable totals for the entire season. But can you fully capitalize on them and avoid the pitfalls?

[kinosh]

No way! Harrison is a top tier WR because of his talent and QB. Galloway may be close in talent (MAYBE!) but Gradkowski is a rookie.