I would give my left nut to have him back with the Giants. The best lefty out of the pen in the National League.
mofome said:win the NL? they start 7 guys or so battin under .200. I think they need a bat, i couldnt see them finishing higher than 4th in either of the other 2 divisions.
just my opinion
Clip Joint said:Yea those Dodgers are dangerous...all 7 runs in the last 5 games.
LOL
You can't count Nomar as he hasn't been healthy in years and even when he is, he is not a productive 1B. He put up great numbers for a SS.
I'll take the Giants combo at 1B of Niekro and Sweeney over the production the Dodgers will get out of 1B.
Kent over Durham for sure.
I'll take Vizquel over Furcal. He is the perfect #2 hitter and does all of the small things needed to hit in that spot. Furcal is not a leadoff hitter and hurts the Dodgers in that position with his inability to take a walk and pathetic OBP. He can have all the speed he wants.
I'll take Feliz over Mueller even though Feliz is my least favorite Giant. He hit .250 with 20 HRs and 81 RBIs last season. Mueller hit .295 with 10 HRs and 62 RBIs while playing in the AL. I'll sacrifice average points any day of the week for power and RBIs at either of the corner positions.
Bonds in a landslide.
Winn in a landslide. He came over from Seattle last year and played in 58 games for the Giants. He hit .359 with 14 HRs and scored 39 runs. Not bad for a leadoff hitter.
Give me Alou over Drew.
I can't see how you would take an injury prone player like Drew that has never had a 100 RBI season over a guy like Alou. Drew had one good season with Atlanta. Other than that he has been mediocre at best. Take a look at Alou's numbers at the end of the season and look at Drew's. It won't even be close and Alou will play less games.
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree.
Clip Joint said:Nomar has a batting title under his belt...LMAO. Come on bro...I could care less what he did back when he knew how to play baseball.
I was starting to lose a little respect for your baseball knowledge. Quoting fantasy league stats doesn't mean much to me. I'll take guys that fill their role. You can't compare offensive numbers of a leadoff hitter to a guy that hits #2 in the batting order. If you don't understand the difference in their jobs, this conversation is meaningless. Omar's job is not to get on base...that is Furcal's job.
Again...Mueller has a higher OPS. LMAO. That's great. I'll still take some power at 3B with more HRs and more RBIs.
Winn isn't as great as I make him out to be? That's odd...all I did was show his stats.
You live and die with this OPS...you would make a poor handicapper and GM, but a great fantasy league player (maybe). I think the Giants would consider the Drew for Alou trade because of age only. Who would you rather have hitting behind Bonds? JD Drew, or Moises Alou...that is a no brainer. Alou is a guy who drives in runs. JD Drew is a guy that has made his career on having "potential".
I'm done with this...pointless conversation when someone starts using OPS and useless stats that don't compare by their spot in the batting order.
Nomar won a batting title so he is good...LMAO!!!