I'm not attacking him, I'm just saying that you can't proof unverified tips.
Ask him, he'll tell you the same thing, which is why it is odd that his proofing service has devolved into, "He said, she said." Fezz supposedly has recently gone 6-0 on tips that Bob never received and Fezz is getting credit for them. I'm no proofing expert but I can tell you that's not how it's done.
It's called. "Proofing" because I need "proof" that you made the selection. If a well-respected Proofer is including unverified tips in the public record then all is lost, in the sense of having an unbiased independent third party share an honest report on a Tipster's performance.
Another losing day for Fezz. Now 1-9 in the last week. Down almost 60 units this year. It's pretty realistic he ends up down over 100 units before football season starts if he doesn't quit baseball like last year.