Jake Odorizzi says not so fast my friend
He's been good. Here's how they stack up:
Innings: Giolito 81 Odorizzi 70
Win/loss record: Giolito 10-1, Odorizzi 9-2
ERA: Giolito 2.22 Odorizzi 1.92
FIP: Giolito 2.69 Odorizzi 2.70
XFIP: Giolito 3.70 Odorizzi 4.22
strikeouts: Giolito 95, Odorizzu 78
walks: Giolito 26, Odorizzi 22
BABIP against: Giolito .249 Odorizzi .251
soft contact: Giolito 20.0% Odorizzi 19.3%
hard contact: Giolito 30.5% Odorizzu 39.8%
complete games: Giolito 2, Odorizzi 0
Expected WOBA: Giolito .266 Odorizzi .284
It's close and both have had a few things go their way, and from a handicapping standpoint, at some point, there will be some regression. But I wouldn't assume its right around the corner. Both are feeling good and pitching with confidence. The ASG is about results; not theoreticals, so their XFIPs should not be held against them.