QB rankings after week 8

Mahomes 3rd in QBR, 4th in YPG, 2nd in EPA, tied for 1st in TD passes, 10th in YPA. Sad how every week you allow your hatred for him to cloud your judgement
 
I know, he's carried by Kelce, the defense, the receivers, the running backs, the coaches, the line, and the fans
 
And if PFF had Mahomes ranked top 5, then you would use another site to get your ratings, what ever site backs up your Mahomes hatred is the one you'll use
 
PFF has Allen #5. I put him 7th. Stop cherry picking. Allen has been much better than Mahomes this year and it's not close. Allen can get those QB sneaks for TDs or first downs.
 
Mahomes 3rd in QBR, Joshy 13th, but Raiders the liar insists Joshy has been much better and it's not even close, LMAO
 
I’d take Nate Silver with a grain of salt, but he is very statistically oriented.
His rankings:

The best and worst QBs of 2025
Every NFL quarterback to play in 2025 by QBERT rating, adjusted QBERT rating, and WAR


Team Player QBERT Adj. QBERT WAR
1 KC Patrick Mahomes 107.3 97.5 +2.9
+2.9+2.9
2 IND Daniel Jones 113.8 102.4 +2.8
+2.8+2.8
3 NE Drake Maye 110.7 99.6 +2.7
+2.7+2.7
4 PHI Jalen Hurts 105.4 95.3 +2.3
+2.3+2.3
5 DAL Dak Prescott 100.7 90.2 +2.1
+2.1+2.1
6 GB Jordan Love 106.2 95.1 +1.9
+1.9+1.9
7 SEA Sam Darnold 109.9 99.2 +1.9
+1.9+1.9
8 LAR Matthew Stafford 102.1 91.9 +1.8
+1.8+1.8
9 LAC Justin Herbert 98.1 85.6 +1.8
+1.8+1.8
10 BUF Josh Allen 102.9 90.9 +1.7
+1.7+1.7
11 DET Jared Goff 103.0 93.9 +1.7
+1.7+1.7
12 TB Baker Mayfield 91.7 82.5 +1.3
+1.3+1.3
13 HOU C.J. Stroud 93.5 83.1 +1.2
+1.2+1.2
14 DEN Bo Nix 91.9 80.6 +1.2
+1.2+1.2
15 BAL Lamar Jackson
 
Silver is a guy I have respect for. Bottom line is different people and sites have these guys ranked in different orders, all I know is any site that has Mahomes ranked 11th can't be taken seriously
 
Crazy Pete said:
I’d take Nate Silver with a grain of salt, but he is very statistically oriented.
His rankings:

The best and worst QBs of 2025
Every NFL quarterback to play in 2025 by QBERT rating, adjusted QBERT rating, and WAR


Team Player QBERT Adj. QBERT WAR
1 KC Patrick Mahomes 107.3 97.5 +2.9
+2.9+2.9
2 IND Daniel Jones 113.8 102.4 +2.8
+2.8+2.8
3 NE Drake Maye 110.7 99.6 +2.7
+2.7+2.7
4 PHI Jalen Hurts 105.4 95.3 +2.3
+2.3+2.3
5 DAL Dak Prescott 100.7 90.2 +2.1
+2.1+2.1
6 GB Jordan Love 106.2 95.1 +1.9
+1.9+1.9
7 SEA Sam Darnold 109.9 99.2 +1.9
+1.9+1.9
8 LAR Matthew Stafford 102.1 91.9 +1.8
+1.8+1.8
9 LAC Justin Herbert 98.1 85.6 +1.8
+1.8+1.8
10 BUF Josh Allen 102.9 90.9 +1.7
+1.7+1.7
11 DET Jared Goff 103.0 93.9 +1.7
+1.7+1.7
12 TB Baker Mayfield 91.7 82.5 +1.3
+1.3+1.3
13 HOU C.J. Stroud 93.5 83.1 +1.2
+1.2+1.2
14 DEN Bo Nix 91.9 80.6 +1.2
+1.2+1.2
15 BAL Lamar Jackson
Click to expand...
There's a difference between future prediction and play to date. My rating is based on play to date similar to PFF.
 
raiders72001 said:
No one ever said that.
Click to expand...
You've said that, you've said it many times, this is why your known as Raiders the liar. You think Mahomes and Alex Smith are the same QB, now you claim you never said it, you're a liar and you know you're lying
 
kane said:
I know, he's carried by Kelce, the defense, the receivers, the running backs, the coaches, the line, and the fans
Click to expand...

Don't forget the GM/front office!


Unrelated note - Is there any better reading than a Raiders/Kane "discussion"? :LOL:

It's like 2 brothers throwing haymakers at each other.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top