It's amazing they didn't handle this differently. Like OP says, this is going to cost them a bid. At this point, Indiana clearly more competitive than OhioSt (w/o KWesson).
Ohio State is 0-3 SU and ATS since Kaleb Wesson's suspension.
Interesting to note: Kaleb's older brother, Andre, has played poorly without his brother on the court, going 4-for-25 from the field over the last three games.