If I'm NFL commissioner...

Valuist

EOG Master
The game would improve significantly. The short sighted, lying fool that is Roger Goodell is a complete incompetent. As big as the game is now, it could be better.

1. Return to a 16 game season. 16 is a good number; 17 is bad. You, as an entity. claim you care about player safety and yet you add another game. This isn't 1970. We now have 255 pound linebackers who can run 4.4 and bench press 500 pounds and squat significantly more. The collisions are much more violent.

2. Start the season the Sunday of Labor Day weekend. This used to be the case. I don't know if it was Goodell or a predecessor who changed this but the reasoning was poor at best. Not everyone goes away on Labor Day weekend. Not everyone has a boat. Not everyone has a vacation home. Does anyone really believe the boating industry is bigger than the NFL? To this point we have gotten a few college football matchups where the Alabamas and Ohio States of the world pile drive an overmatched opponent into submission. People are craving football games that aren't over before halftime. And if you think the boating crowd and vacation home crowd wouldn't adapt? There's a line from a recent movie; "the church used to own Sundays.....until the NFL took it from them." The vacation crowd would adapt.

3. Elimination of Thursday night games. Again, you as the NFL claim you care about player safety yet you have teams playing games a mere 4 days after their previous game. But you just have to have that prime time money.....yet put the games on a buffoon network like Prime. Anyone with a pulse realizes the quality of these games is not good. They try to mask the problem by having mostly divisional matchups but that's only putting lipstick on a pig. You can keep the two T-Giving games in Detroit and Dallas. That's it. The other aspect is teams coming off 10 days rest are at an unfair advantage when playing opponents returning in 7, or even 6 days.

4. Thursday night prime time games move to Saturday night. What? And step on the toes of hallowed college football? College football is nothing more than a minor league feeding ground for the NFL. Can you imagine David Stern looking at the G-League schedule when creating a schedule for an upcoming season? Or MLB not wanting to go head to head with the Pacific Coast League? It's laughable. College football can still have early and late afternoon. BTW, college football steps on high school football now by playing Friday night games. Why should they be immune? If they don't like it, get a better product.

5. Changes in pass interference rules. Limit PI to 20 yards. What? Too big of an advantage for the defense? If a defender gets flagged for a 2nd PI, it's an automatic ejection.

6. Change the touchback rule. I've railed against this rule in the past and like many, I believe its the worst (OK, second worst now that MLB has an invisible runner in extra innings) rule in sports. I'm referring to touchbacks where the offensive player fumbles the ball through/out of the end zone. Logically the offense should retain possession at the 1 yard line. I'm willing to even penalize the offense. Give them possession back at the 10 yard line. Possession doesn't change so if team A had the ball 2nd and goal from the 4, gets the near TD to fumble out of bounds in the end zone, its now 3rd and goal from the 10. Change of possession is crazy.

7. Back to one wild card for each conference. Stop rewarding mediocrity.

8. No 2 weeks between Conference championships and the Super Bowl. Football should never be played in the month of February.

9. Eliminate all UK and Germany games. The NFL will never have a team based in Europe in our lifetimes. Never.

My objective would be to improve the game, not provide more short term profits for Jerry Jones and David Tepper. But what they fail to realize, is my changes likely would mean more money for them in the long run.
 
Last edited:

ZzyzxRoad

EOG Dedicated
The game would improve significantly. The short sighted, lying fool that is Roger Goodell is a complete incompetent. As big as the game is now, it could be better.

1. Return to a 16 game season. 16 is a good number; 17 is bad. You, as an entity. claim you care about player safety and yet you add another game. This isn't 1970. We now have 255 pound linebackers who can run 4.4 and bench press 500 pounds and squat significantly more. The collisions are much more violent.

2. Start the season the Sunday of Labor Day weekend. This used to be the case. I don't know if it was Goodell or a predecessor who changed this but the reasoning was poor at best. Not everyone goes away on Labor Day weekend. Not everyone has a boat. Not everyone has a vacation home. Does anyone really believe the boating industry is bigger than the NFL? To this point we have gotten a few college football matchups where the Alabamas and Ohio States of the world pile drive an overmatched opponent into submission. People are craving football games that aren't over before halftime. And if you think the boating crowd and vacation home crowd wouldn't adapt? There's a line from a recent movie; "the church used to own Sundays.....until the NFL took it from them." The vacation crowd would adapt.

3. Elimination of Thursday night games. Again, you as the NFL claim you care about player safety yet you have teams playing games a mere 4 days after their previous game. But you just have to have that prime time money.....yet put the games on a buffoon network like Prime. Anyone with a pulse realizes the quality of these games is not good. They try to mask the problem by having mostly divisional matchups but that's only putting lipstick on a pig. You can keep the two T-Giving games in Detroit and Dallas. That's it. The other aspect is teams coming off 10 days rest are at an unfair advantage when playing opponents returning in 7, or even 6 days.

4. Thursday night prime time games move to Saturday night. What? And step on the toes of hallowed college football? College football is nothing more than a minor league feeding ground for the NFL. Can you imagine David Stern looking at the G-League schedule when creating a schedule for an upcoming season? Or MLB not wanting to go head to head with the Pacific Coast League? It's laughable. College football can still have early and late afternoon. BTW, college football steps on high school football now by playing Friday night games. Why should they be immune? If they don't like it, get a better product.

5. Changes in pass interference rules. Limit PI to 20 yards. What? Too big of an advantage for the defense? If a defender gets flagged for a 2nd PI, it's an automatic ejection.

6. Change the touchback rule. I've railed against this rule in the past and like many, I believe its the worst (OK, second worst now that MLB has an invisible runner in extra innings) rule in sports. I'm referring to touchbacks where the offensive player fumbles the ball through/out of the end zone. Logically the offense should retain possession at the 1 yard line. I'm willing to even penalize the offense. Give them possession back at the 10 yard line. Possession doesn't change so if team A had the ball 2nd and goal from the 4, gets the near TD to fumble out of bounds in the end zone, its now 3rd and goal from the 10. Change of possession is crazy.

7. Back to one wild card for each conference. Stop rewarding mediocrity.

8. No 2 weeks between Conference championships and the Super Bowl. Football should never be played in the month of February.

9. Eliminate all UK and Germany games. The NFL will never have a team based in Europe in our lifetimes. Never.

My objective would be to improve the game, not provide more short term profits for Jerry Jones and David Tepper. But what they fail to realize, is my changes likely would mean more money for them in the long run.

I disagree with number 8, and the second part of number 5. The rest of the post is useful and informative.
 

Dell Dude

EOG Master
Here is one for you, Valuetryst.

If I was made NFLe commissioner, 4 pee season, earlier regular season start, 16 consecutive no bye weeks and only play on Sunday unless special needs like Thanksgiving, Christmas and Saturday when college football ends. College, same thing. Only Saturday. 12 consecutive weeks, original conferences, original bowls. Natty on Super Show weekend.
 

choslamshe

EOG Master
The second part of the PI could maybe get re-worked. We should never see 40 and 50 yard penalties. Ever.
Agreed. Especially with how subjective these calls are. Based on the penalties that are called in any game, by any crew, one could find another 5-10 calls per game for the same infractions that get missed.

Too large an impact by some of the most incompetent crews out there.
 

Dell Dude

EOG Master
It doesn't matter. Not only none of these things will happen, new rules and changes will make it worse and worse. Always one way traffic. College is falling first. NFLe will follow.
 

boston massacre

EOG Master
The game would improve significantly. The short sighted, lying fool that is Roger Goodell is a complete incompetent. As big as the game is now, it could be better.

1. Return to a 16 game season. 16 is a good number; 17 is bad. You, as an entity. claim you care about player safety and yet you add another game. This isn't 1970. We now have 255 pound linebackers who can run 4.4 and bench press 500 pounds and squat significantly more. The collisions are much more violent.

2. Start the season the Sunday of Labor Day weekend. This used to be the case. I don't know if it was Goodell or a predecessor who changed this but the reasoning was poor at best. Not everyone goes away on Labor Day weekend. Not everyone has a boat. Not everyone has a vacation home. Does anyone really believe the boating industry is bigger than the NFL? To this point we have gotten a few college football matchups where the Alabamas and Ohio States of the world pile drive an overmatched opponent into submission. People are craving football games that aren't over before halftime. And if you think the boating crowd and vacation home crowd wouldn't adapt? There's a line from a recent movie; "the church used to own Sundays.....until the NFL took it from them." The vacation crowd would adapt.

3. Elimination of Thursday night games. Again, you as the NFL claim you care about player safety yet you have teams playing games a mere 4 days after their previous game. But you just have to have that prime time money.....yet put the games on a buffoon network like Prime. Anyone with a pulse realizes the quality of these games is not good. They try to mask the problem by having mostly divisional matchups but that's only putting lipstick on a pig. You can keep the two T-Giving games in Detroit and Dallas. That's it. The other aspect is teams coming off 10 days rest are at an unfair advantage when playing opponents returning in 7, or even 6 days.

4. Thursday night prime time games move to Saturday night. What? And step on the toes of hallowed college football? College football is nothing more than a minor league feeding ground for the NFL. Can you imagine David Stern looking at the G-League schedule when creating a schedule for an upcoming season? Or MLB not wanting to go head to head with the Pacific Coast League? It's laughable. College football can still have early and late afternoon. BTW, college football steps on high school football now by playing Friday night games. Why should they be immune? If they don't like it, get a better product.

5. Changes in pass interference rules. Limit PI to 20 yards. What? Too big of an advantage for the defense? If a defender gets flagged for a 2nd PI, it's an automatic ejection.

6. Change the touchback rule. I've railed against this rule in the past and like many, I believe its the worst (OK, second worst now that MLB has an invisible runner in extra innings) rule in sports. I'm referring to touchbacks where the offensive player fumbles the ball through/out of the end zone. Logically the offense should retain possession at the 1 yard line. I'm willing to even penalize the offense. Give them possession back at the 10 yard line. Possession doesn't change so if team A had the ball 2nd and goal from the 4, gets the near TD to fumble out of bounds in the end zone, its now 3rd and goal from the 10. Change of possession is crazy.

7. Back to one wild card for each conference. Stop rewarding mediocrity.

8. No 2 weeks between Conference championships and the Super Bowl. Football should never be played in the month of February.

9. Eliminate all UK and Germany games. The NFL will never have a team based in Europe in our lifetimes. Never.

My objective would be to improve the game, not provide more short term profits for Jerry Jones and David Tepper. But what they fail to realize, is my changes likely would mean more money for them in the long run.


Agree on # 3 and # 9 .

# 1 ? Most Popular Sport in America. Don't Take Away Games, Add 1 More , For an Even 18 Game Schedule.

# 2 Current Start is Perfect. Summer Over. Then You Ask : ARE YOU READY FOR SOME FOOTBALL ? YES BOX Wins Overwhelmingly.

But, The Ending Should Be on a Holiday Weekend. Schedule Super Bowl Every Year on Sunday, of President's Day Holiday Weekend.

Once Super Bowl is Over, it's on To That Big Long Dragged Out Sport of Baseball , Which Happens EVERY SINGLE DAY OF THE

WEEK . FOR 6 STRAIGHT MONTHS !!


1 Last Very Important Important Thing For The Commissioner :

Get Rid of All These Football Programs, That Nickel and Dime People.

Amazon Prime
Peacock
NFL +
 

Heim

EOG Master
I'm really mixed on the defensive holding auto first down. It usually occurs on 3rd down penalizing a team for good defense overall. On the
flip side a team will always hold if a guy is getting free if it's only a slap on the wrist, no auto first down.

A compromise, spot foul, if enough for a first down...fine.
 

mr merlin

EOG Master
I'd get rid of the planned celebrations after a turnover where the entire defense runs 60-70 yds sometimes to pose and hop around in the end zone. Often it's done by a team that is losing or it's not even a scoring play. they'll even do it and then the play is reversed after replay.

No more acting like wild animals on non scoring plays.
 

Valuist

EOG Master
I'm really mixed on the defensive holding auto first down. It usually occurs on 3rd down penalizing a team for good defense overall. On the
flip side a team will always hold if a guy is getting free if it's only a slap on the wrist, no auto first down.

A compromise, spot foul, if enough for a first down...fine.

Agreed. Some compromise on the hold. Still 5 yards and auto 1st down if 10 yards or less needed for the first down. I'm sick of seeing teams on 3rd and 16 get the 1st down because of the 5 yard penalty.
 

Dell Dude

EOG Master
Imagine that, 100k posts or so and I missed/forgot one.
Mine are short and simple. 4 pee season. 16 regular season. Wild card. Division. Conference. Super Show.

Consecutive except week between conference and Show. Sundays only with SNF except Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Years and Saturdays after college football.

Home and away. No shithole countries. 3 networks. CBS, FOX, NBC. Can sir mixalot every new TV contract.

None of that will happen because doesn't maximize betting profit which is the only thing that matters other than serving the NFLe's woke masters.
 

Valuist

EOG Master
Mine are short and simple. 4 pee season. 16 regular season. Wild card. Division. Conference. Super Show.

Consecutive except week between conference and Show. Sundays only with SNF except Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Years and Saturdays after college football.

Home and away. No shithole countries. 3 networks. CBS, FOX, NBC. Can sir mixalot every new TV contract.

None of that will happen because doesn't maximize betting profit which is the only thing that matters other than serving the NFLe's woke masters.
I don't disagree with any of that and in the long run the league would benefit. Including betting handle.

Boston Massacre wants more games. Nope. Part of what makes the NFL great is the vast majority of games matter. Unlike the NBA or MLB. And more games means more injuries, which just dilutes the product.
 

boston massacre

EOG Master
I don't disagree with any of that and in the long run the league would benefit. Including betting handle.

Boston Massacre wants more games. Nope. Part of what makes the NFL great is the vast majority of games matter. Unlike the NBA or MLB. And more games means more injuries, which just dilutes the product.

Baseball /162

Basketball/ 82

Hockey/ 82

Football/ 18

And When Talking About Shortening a Season , You Mention The Sport , With BY FAR , The Least Amount Of Games.

Then You Mention How Football Shouldn't Be Played in February.

Baseball Goes into November.

I'd Like To Series a World Series Game Scheduled in 5 Below Zero Weather.

It Would Be a Good Test, To See Weather The Sport Would Play The Game at 5 Below, or Wimp Out and Cancel Until it Warmed Up.


Part of what makes the NFL great is the vast majority of games matter.

100 % Correct on That.

And Going From 17 to 18 Would ADD , Another Game That Matters.
 

TonyMar

EOG Dedicated
Really like the return to classical 16 games.

What about Saturday night,..flex games?

that begin around midway thru the season or later.. to avoid competing 100% with NCAA.
 

TonyMar

EOG Dedicated
Agree on # 3 and # 9 .

# 1 ? Most Popular Sport in America. Don't Take Away Games, Add 1 More , For an Even 18 Game Schedule.

# 2 Current Start is Perfect. Summer Over. Then You Ask : ARE YOU READY FOR SOME FOOTBALL ? YES BOX Wins Overwhelmingly.

But, The Ending Should Be on a Holiday Weekend. Schedule Super Bowl Every Year on Sunday, of President's Day Holiday Weekend.

Once Super Bowl is Over, it's on To That Big Long Dragged Out Sport of Baseball , Which Happens EVERY SINGLE DAY OF THE

WEEK . FOR 6 STRAIGHT MONTHS !!


1 Last Very Important Important Thing For The Commissioner :

Get Rid of All These Football Programs, That Nickel and Dime People.

Amazon Prime
Peacock
NFL +

Which is the reality. Nfl ratings destroy Nba on Christmas Day.. while they give 1 great matchup and 2 awful ones….

So, unlikely owners will ever agree to less games now… they are printing money hand over first…Amazing how each receive end of season checks in the 90 mill range, on top of in-season profits.
 

Valuist

EOG Master
I think Drew Martin from the Wagerline Opening Line report read this post. He basically addressed why he feels the NFL doesn't go harder after NCAAF (Saturdays).

Boston-

Yes MLB goes into November. It shouldn't. 2 wrongs don't make a right. Cut MLB to 125 games and NBA to 60 games. I only want to cut the NFL by about 6-7 pct.,
 

howid

EOG Dedicated
NFLPA agreed to a 17 game season, highly unlikely they would take a pay cut to go back to 16 ...
 

boston massacre

EOG Master
I think Drew Martin from the Wagerline Opening Line report read this post. He basically addressed why he feels the NFL doesn't go harder after NCAAF (Saturdays).

Boston-

Yes MLB goes into November. It shouldn't. 2 wrongs don't make a right. Cut MLB to 125 games and NBA to 60 games. I only want to cut the NFL by about 6-7 pct.,

Cut ?

For What Reason ?

By Far, It is The Most Successful Sport in America .

NFL FOOTBALL IS KING !

Yearly Revenue and Games Per Season Prove It.


MLB / 162 Games/ 10.8 Billion


NBA/ 82 Games / 10.5 Billion


NFL / 17 Games / 11.9 Billion

NFL Plays 11 % of The Amount of Games That MLB Plays , YET , They Take in 1 Billion Dollars More Per Year in Revenue.


NFL is The Undisputed Champion , as Proved By its Fans and Followers.


Give Me 1 Reason WHY, You Would Want To Cut Down on That Success.
 

Valuist

EOG Master
Cut ?

For What Reason ?

By Far, It is The Most Successful Sport in America .

NFL FOOTBALL IS KING !

Yearly Revenue and Games Per Season Prove It.


MLB / 162 Games/ 10.8 Billion


NBA/ 82 Games / 10.5 Billion


NFL / 17 Games / 11.9 Billion

NFL Plays 11 % of The Amount of Games That MLB Plays , YET , They Take in 1 Billion Dollars More Per Year in Revenue.


NFL is The Undisputed Champion , as Proved By its Fans and Followers.


Give Me 1 Reason WHY, You Would Want To Cut Down on That Success.

Injuries. Injuries dilute the product.

The QB play right now, league wide, is as poor as I can remember.

Expansion would mean more games. That would be better, right? No, it would be a huge mistake.
 
Top