De La Cruz, best player in the game

FairWarning

Bells Beer Connoisseur
Babe Ruth wants to talk with you….lol
Ruth’s pitching career was over very early, Ohtani has been doing both. The test now is how long can Ohtani do both. He may never approach his hitting numbers, but he could blow away the pitching. That could place Ohtani top 5-10 all time.
 

Valuist

EOG Master
Ruth’s pitching career was over very early, Ohtani has been doing both. The test now is how long can Ohtani do both. He may never approach his hitting numbers, but he could blow away the pitching. That could place Ohtani top 5-10 all time.
If he is still pitching at an elite level 5 years from now, he’s the GOAT. How many shutouts did Willie Mays throw? What was Mickey Mantle’s XFIP? Who would be ahead of him? How many black, Latin and Asian players did Ruth play against?
 

Patrick McIrish

OCCams raZOR
Babe Ruth wants to talk with you….lol

Switch the two players.

Babe is trying his best to get to single A ball in today's game.....

Ohtani is so dominant he's probably burned at the stake for being some kind of "witch".

The Babe is a cool story but probably not a top 5000 player of the game outside his era.
 
You can't compare players in the 1920s to today. Babe Ruth was the most dominant player in his prime at that time and it wasn't close. He hit more HRs than some teams. Then pitching he threw 35 complete games one year and 9 shut outs another year.

We don't know what he would do today. He may have been a workout warrior eating proper nutrition. If he saw a 95 MPH fastball baseball through the minor leagues, he may have adapted. He can't be penalized for something we don't know. We can just compare him to others at that same time.
 

Valuist

EOG Master
How tough is it to be good in MLB? You take a guy like De La Cruz, amazing tools and talent, but after a number of at bats, the league figures them out. He may very well get things figure out, but he will have to:

1693596176938.png
 

MrTop

EOG Master
anybody that whiffs that much 37.8 % cannot hit, although early for that kid on the reds..... he has to make contact or he will be out of MLB


tatis of the padres when he first came up did the same thing. then the drugs

my man swarber .226 lifetime whiffs at 28%


in the history of the game only judge has got away with a lifetime high strikeout rate at 28.8% and a .281 avg..............his avg will continue to drop it is early.


easier to be a slugger than a great hitter
 
Top