So you have no problem with the ban, but rather a problem with the length of the ban.
You want seven days, not 30.
Minor disagreement.
The thought process behind the 30-day ban was WINKY's term in the Grand Challenge thread.
Not long ago, KANE, you requested me to recruit WINKY back to EOG.
WINK left because of DUDE'S boorish behavior.
Exactly, I understand the reasoning behind the ban, I get it. What I have a problem with is the length. In hindsight, don't you think a one week ban along with a warning that if he messes with Winky again he'll get a full month would have been the way to go?
Why didn't you just give him a week and a warning? I'd really appreciate an answer to this question. John, you've been here for 16 years, in all that time
have you ever banned someone for 4 weeks? I know you've given out one week bans, and on occasion perma bans, but have you ever handed someone a 4 week ban? I'd appreciate an answer to this question as well. I've told you privately in the past that I respect you and have commended you on how you run this place, but I honestly think you messed up this time, I don't think you thought about the long term ramifications, you expect Dell to take his medicine and come back like nothing happened, but there's a very real chance he doesn't come back, in fact I'd make no return the favorite.
Let's say you had to do it over again, and you knew for a fact that giving Dell a 4 week ban meant him leaving for good, would you still have done it, or would you have gone with my suggestion of one week and a warning? For the sake of EOG's future I implore you to re-consider and change the ban to one week with a warning, you don't spend a lot of time here, so maybe you don't realize just how important Dell is to this place, his thread is by far the most popular and probably the most viewed ever in terms of views per day. Also, yes I asked you to try and get Winky back, I like him, and my defense of Dell has nothing to do with him. However, I don't understand how Winky could have left because of Dell's "boorish behavior" since he has him on ignore, it doesn't make any sense, having him on ignore means he doesn't see any of Dell's posts anyway, so how could he have been bothered by them? It's my understanding, and Winky can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think Winky left when Trump won the election, he didn't want to deal with the maga morons, so he left, I'm not positive on this and if I'm wrong Winky can correct me, but either way how could someone leave here due to another members posts when that person has him on ignore, doesn't make sense. It's not to late to do the right thing John.
#FreeDell